Pumpkin beer season is here, and by now you’ve probably seen a pretty wide range of them.
There are the easy-drinking ones that give you a little cinnamon and nutmeg without taking over your palate. Then you have the big pumpkin beers that taste like someone put Thanksgiving dessert in a can. Somewhere in between are amber ales, brown ales and spiced beers that use pumpkin as one piece of a much bigger recipe.
That raises a pretty simple question:
What actually goes into a pumpkin beer?
The answer is more interesting than you might think.
Yes, some breweries use real pumpkin. Others use pumpkin puree. Spices are common, but they aren’t the whole story. The malt bill, hops, yeast, fermentation and even the timing of each ingredient all affect what eventually ends up in your glass.
Let’s follow one from start to the finish.
1. First, You Need a Beer
Pumpkin isn’t the starting point.
The brewer first has to decide what kind of beer will carry all those fall flavors. That could mean an amber ale, brown ale, porter or another malt-forward beer. The base recipe matters because pumpkin doesn’t magically turn any beer into a pumpkin beer. A light, crisp ale will give you a very different result from a rich, caramel-heavy amber.
Take Samuel Adams Jack-O as an example. It’s a relatively light 4.4% pumpkin ale built with pale malt and malted wheat, Hallertau hops and ale yeast. The brewery describes it as combining real pumpkin with cinnamon, nutmeg and other autumn spices.
Compare that with Lancaster Brewing’s Baked Pumpkin Ale. At 7.5% ABV, its recipe leans much bigger, using caramel, Munich and Vienna malts along with fresh pumpkin and a blend of spices. Same general category. Completely different foundation.
That’s something you’ll notice with pumpkin beer more than you might expect. The pumpkin gets the attention, but the beer underneath it still does a lot of the work.
2. Now Find Some Pumpkin
Here’s where things get interesting.
Brewers have several ways to get pumpkin into the recipe. Fresh pumpkin can be roasted and processed. Canned pumpkin puree is another option. Some recipes use pumpkin in the mash, while others add it later in the brewing process.
Brooklyn Post Road Pumpkin Ale is a good example of a brewery leaning into the real thing. Brooklyn says Post Road uses pounds of real Dickinson pumpkins and highlights warming nutmeg in the finished beer. It’s a 5% pumpkin ale available as a fall seasonal.
Cape May takes a different route with Pick of the Batch. The brewery says the beer is made with real pumpkin and that its pumpkins are hand-carved and roasted, with cinnamon and vanilla playing supporting roles. The current version is 6% ABV.
That roasting step isn’t just for show. Cooking pumpkin changes its texture and helps make its starches more useful during brewing. Roasting can also contribute some deeper flavors that fit naturally with the malt and spices.
Of course, pumpkin creates a practical problem, too. It’s wet. It’s pulpy. And breweries don’t exactly love having a giant pile of vegetable matter clogging up their equipment.
That’s why brewers have to think about where the pumpkin goes and how much they use.
3. Into the Mash It Goes
For some pumpkin beers, the pumpkin is added during the mash.
The mash is the stage where hot water meets crushed malted grain. Enzymes in the grain break down starches into sugars that yeast can later ferment.
Pumpkin brings additional starch and sugar into that environment. Cooking it beforehand helps make those starches more accessible.
There is another reason brewers need to pay attention here: pumpkin can make the mash harder to drain. The extra material can slow down the separation of wort from the grain, which is why brewers may use techniques such as adding rice hulls to improve the flow.
The goal isn’t to make pumpkin soup. You want the useful parts of the pumpkin to contribute to the wort without turning the brewing system into a plumbing nightmare.
4. The Wort Hits the Kettle
Once the mash is finished, the brewer separates the liquid wort from the grain.
That wort goes into the kettle, where it gets boiled and hops are added according to the recipe. Hops may not be the star of a pumpkin beer, but they still matter. Bitterness keeps the malt and any sweetness from becoming overwhelming.
This is particularly important with the bigger pumpkin ales. Lancaster Baked, for example, has 20 IBUs despite all those rich malt and pumpkin flavors.
The brewer can also add pumpkin during the boil rather than putting it entirely in the mash. There isn’t one universal method. Different breweries have different equipment, recipes and ideas about how much pumpkin character they want.
That’s one reason you can drink five pumpkin beers and swear they came from five completely different categories.
5. Then Come the Spices
Now we’re getting into the flavors most people associate with pumpkin beer.
Cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, allspice, clove, vanilla.
Those ingredients are responsible for a lot of the “pumpkin pie” character we recognize. Pumpkin itself can contribute flavor, but it isn’t necessarily going to taste like a slice of pie on its own.
Samuel Adams Jack-O uses cinnamon and nutmeg. Cape May’s Pick of the Batch highlights cinnamon, nutmeg and vanilla. Cigar City’s Good Gourd takes the spice approach considerably further with cinnamon, allspice, cloves, nutmeg and vanilla.
And then there’s the question of when those spices go in.
Brewers can add them toward the end of the boil, during fermentation or later during conditioning. Adding them later gives the brewer more control over the final intensity. That’s important because spices can go from “nice touch” to “cinnamon challenge” surprisingly quickly.
The best pumpkin beers usually have enough spice to tell you exactly what season it is without completely burying the beer underneath it.
6. Don’t Forget the Hops
Pumpkin beers aren’t hopless.
They simply tend to use hops differently from an IPA or pale ale. A brewer might want a small amount of bitterness to balance the malt and residual sweetness without introducing a big citrus, pine or tropical character.
Samuel Adams Jack-O, for example, comes in at just 8 IBUs and uses Hallertau-Hallertau hops. Cape May’s Pick of the Batch is listed at 13 IBUs. That gives you a good idea of the general direction.
The hops are there, but they’re usually supporting the recipe rather than demanding your attention.
7. Cool It Down and Let the Yeast Work
After the boil, the wort needs to be cooled.
Then yeast gets added. This is where the beer actually becomes alcoholic. Yeast consumes fermentable sugars and produces alcohol and carbon dioxide, along with a whole collection of compounds that influence the beer’s aroma and flavor.
The yeast isn’t making pumpkin flavor (in nearly all cases). It’s helping turn the wort created by the earlier stages into beer. That distinction matters because by the time fermentation begins, the brewer has already built much of the foundation. The yeast now gets to transform it.
For a beer like Jack-O, that means an ale fermentation. Other pumpkin beers can use different fermentation approaches depending on the base style.
During this stage, the beer will also lose some of the sweetness from the original wort. That’s why the finished beer doesn’t simply taste like sugary pumpkin juice.
8. Now the Brewer Has to Taste It
Fermentation doesn’t mean the beer is finished.
Once the yeast has done its work, the brewer can condition the beer and make adjustments. This is particularly useful for pumpkin beers because spices can be added or adjusted later in the process. Imagine you made a huge batch of pumpkin beer and realized the cinnamon wasn’t quite coming through.
You don’t necessarily need to scrap the batch. A brewer can make controlled additions during conditioning and taste the results along the way.
This is where experience becomes important. Pumpkin beer has a lot of moving pieces, and the brewer needs to keep the malt, alcohol, pumpkin and spices from fighting each other.
9. Then You Package It
Eventually, the beer is ready for cans, bottles or kegs.
For a seasonal beer, timing becomes especially important. Breweries don’t want to start making pumpkin beer when the leaves are already changing. The beer needs time to brew, ferment, condition and get packaged before it reaches the store.
That’s why pumpkin beer can start appearing while it’s still hot outside.
Samuel Adams lists Jack-O as an August-through-October seasonal, while Brooklyn lists Post Road Pumpkin from August through November. Lancaster also lists Baked Pumpkin as available beginning in August. This is why most beers use puree of pumpkins from the year before rather than this year’s harvest. One of the only ones I know of in our area that use current year pumpkins is Troegs Master of Pumpkin.
The brewers have to plan ahead.
So Which Pumpkin Beer Shows You What?
This is where things get fun because you can actually taste the differences.
Samuel Adams Jack-O
At 4.4% ABV, Jack-O is one of the lighter examples here. Real pumpkin, cinnamon and nutmeg give it the recognizable fall profile without turning it into a giant dessert beer.
If you want something that says pumpkin without becoming a commitment, this is a good example of that approach.
Brooklyn Post Road Pumpkin
Post Road Pumpkin leans into the actual pumpkin. Brooklyn says it uses pounds of real Dickinson pumpkins, with nutmeg contributing to the finished profile. At 5% ABV, it sits comfortably in the middle of this group.
This is a useful beer to think about when someone asks, “Does pumpkin beer actually have pumpkin in it?”
In this case, yes.
Cape May Pick of the Batch
Pick of the Batch brings roasted pumpkin, cinnamon and vanilla together at 6% ABV. Cape May’s own description specifically calls out hand-carved, roasted pumpkins.
That roasting step makes this a good example of how the treatment of the ingredient can matter just as much as the ingredient itself.
Lancaster Baked Pumpkin
Baked Pumpkin Ale goes bigger.
At 7.5% ABV, Lancaster uses caramel, Munich and Vienna malts alongside fresh pumpkin and its spice blend. The result is designed to evoke pumpkin pie, but the malt bill gives the beer a substantial base underneath those flavors.
This is the kind of pumpkin beer that feels more like a cold-weather beer than a casual porch beer.
Cigar City Good Gourd
Then you have Good Gourd.
Cigar City currently lists it among its beers as a Pumpkin Ale, and the current version is an imperial pumpkin ale at 8.8% ABV. It uses pumpkin alongside cinnamon, allspice, cloves, nutmeg and vanilla.
That’s a very different proposition from Jack-O.
The ABV is higher, the spice bill is more extensive and the whole thing is built to be a bigger beer.
So when someone says they don’t like pumpkin beer, I always think there’s an important follow-up question:
Which pumpkin beer?
And Then There’s Pumpkin Cider
Pumpkin season doesn’t belong exclusively to beer.
If you like the fall flavors but don’t want a malt-based drink, pumpkin cider is a pretty natural alternative.
Downeast Pumpkin is made with an unfiltered blend of apples, pumpkin and chai spices. The current ingredient list includes pumpkin puree, while the cider remains built around fresh-pressed apple cider.
That creates a completely different starting point.
Instead of malt, hops and ale yeast creating the foundation, you’ve got fresh-pressed apples bringing acidity and fruit character. The pumpkin and chai spices then push it toward the same general fall territory as pumpkin beer. I personally love both this and the cider donut.
It’s a good reminder that “pumpkin flavor” doesn’t have to mean pumpkin ale.
So, What’s Actually in Your Pumpkin Beer?
Maybe fresh pumpkin.
Maybe puree.
Definitely some combination of malt, water, hops and yeast.
Possibly cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, allspice, clove or vanilla.
And probably a lot more planning than you realized.
That’s what I like about seasonal beers. You can grab a six-pack because the label looks like fall, and/or you can think about what the brewer did to get that flavor into the can.
Next time you crack open a pumpkin beer, pay attention to what you’re tasting.
Is it the pumpkin?
The malt?
The cinnamon?
The vanilla?
Maybe it’s the combination that makes it work.
And if you’re standing in the beer store trying to decide between Jack-O, Post Road, Pick of the Batch, Baked Pumpkin and Good Gourd, at least now you know they’re not all trying to make the same beer.
Facebook Comments